Orton Vs. Mahal: WWE Rivalry Revisited (2018)

The Randy Orton vs. Jinder Mahal rivalry in 2017-2018 was a rather polarizing period in WWE history. Mahal's sudden ascent to the WWE Championship picture was met with both surprise and skepticism, while Orton, a seasoned veteran, found himself in the unfamiliar position of chasing the title against a relatively new main event player. This article dives deep into the feud, examining its key moments, the reactions it elicited, and ultimately, its place in the annals of WWE history. It's interesting to look back and dissect the storyline, the matches, and the overall impact it had on both superstars' careers. We'll explore the build-up, the championship matches, and the aftermath, providing a comprehensive overview for those who experienced it firsthand and those discovering it for the first time.

The Unexpected Rise of Jinder Mahal

Before diving into the Orton-Mahal feud, it's crucial to understand the context surrounding Jinder Mahal's sudden push. For years, Mahal was considered a lower-card performer, often used in comedic roles or as enhancement talent. His transformation into a serious contender for the WWE Championship was nothing short of shocking. This unexpected elevation was reportedly a strategic move by WWE to expand its market in India, capitalizing on Mahal's Indian heritage. Whatever the reason, the company invested heavily in repackaging Mahal, giving him a new physique, a menacing demeanor, and the backing of the Singh Brothers. This revamped persona quickly gained traction, and Mahal soon found himself in the crosshairs of Randy Orton, then the reigning WWE Champion.

The initial reaction to Mahal's push was mixed. Some fans appreciated the attempt to create a new star and diversify the main event scene. Others criticized the move as feeling forced and inorganic, arguing that Mahal hadn't earned the opportunity through consistent performances and compelling storylines. Regardless of opinion, Mahal's sudden rise undeniably generated buzz and intrigue, making the Orton-Mahal feud one of the most talked-about rivalries of that year. The storyline became a symbol of WWE's willingness to take risks and experiment with its talent, even if it meant deviating from established norms and fan expectations. This risk-taking approach is what keeps the WWE universe engaged, always wondering what surprise the company has in store.

The Viper vs. The Modern-Day Maharaja: Key Moments

The Orton vs. Mahal rivalry officially began in the spring of 2017, culminating in their first championship encounter at Backlash. Mahal, with the help of the Singh Brothers, defeated Orton to capture the WWE Championship, marking a monumental upset. This victory sent shockwaves through the WWE universe, instantly establishing Mahal as a legitimate threat. The match itself was a hard-fought battle, with Orton showcasing his experience and resilience against Mahal's newfound aggression and the constant interference from his allies.

Their feud continued with rematches at Money in the Bank and Battleground. These encounters were characterized by intense physicality and increasingly underhanded tactics from Mahal and the Singh Brothers. Orton, known for his calculated and methodical approach, found himself constantly battling against the odds, often falling victim to the numbers game. At Money in the Bank, Orton won by disqualification after Mahal assaulted him with the Khallas, while at Battleground, Orton lost in a Punjabi Prison Match. This stipulation, chosen by Mahal, added a unique element to the rivalry, paying homage to The Great Khali. The Punjabi Prison Match, with its towering bamboo structures, provided a visually stunning backdrop for their clash, further emphasizing the cultural undertones of the feud. Although Mahal retained his title throughout this period, Orton's pursuit of the championship remained a central theme on SmackDown Live.

The rivalry also took a personal turn, with Mahal targeting Orton's legendary status and his family's legacy. This added a layer of animosity to their matches, making them more than just championship contests. Orton, in turn, sought to dismantle Mahal's carefully constructed empire, aiming to expose him as an unworthy champion. The personal nature of the feud resonated with fans, adding emotional weight to their confrontations. This personal aspect helped to keep the audience invested, even if they were not completely sold on Mahal's championship reign.

Fan Reactions and Critical Reception

As mentioned earlier, the Orton-Mahal feud received mixed reactions from fans and critics alike. While some appreciated the novelty of seeing a new face in the main event picture, others felt that Mahal's push was premature and undeserved. Many argued that Mahal's in-ring skills were not on par with other top-tier performers and that his championship reign was detracting from the overall quality of SmackDown Live.

Critics also pointed to the repetitive nature of their matches, often relying on interference from the Singh Brothers. This predictability made it difficult for fans to fully invest in the storyline. However, some acknowledged the strategic brilliance behind Mahal's character and his ability to generate heat, even if it wasn't always positive. Mahal embraced his role as a villain, using his mic skills to effectively antagonize the audience and establish himself as a credible threat.

Ultimately, the success of a wrestling storyline hinges on its ability to captivate and entertain the audience. While the Orton-Mahal feud had its moments of intrigue, it failed to resonate with a significant portion of the WWE fanbase. This lack of widespread approval ultimately contributed to its limited shelf life, as WWE eventually moved in a different direction.

The Aftermath and Lasting Impact

Jinder Mahal's reign as WWE Champion eventually came to an end when he was defeated by AJ Styles in November 2017. While Mahal's title run was relatively short-lived, it undoubtedly left a lasting impact on his career. It elevated his profile and established him as a legitimate main event player, even if he didn't maintain that status in the long run.

For Randy Orton, the feud with Mahal served as a reminder of his enduring star power and his ability to adapt to different opponents and storylines. Despite being a veteran of the industry, Orton continued to perform at a high level, showcasing his versatility and experience. He proved that he could still hang with the new generation of superstars and contribute to compelling narratives.

Looking back, the Orton-Mahal rivalry represents a unique chapter in WWE history. It was a bold experiment that challenged conventional wisdom and pushed the boundaries of what was considered possible. While it may not have been universally acclaimed, it sparked conversations and generated memorable moments, contributing to the ever-evolving landscape of professional wrestling.

Conclusion

The Randy Orton vs. Jinder Mahal feud of 2017-2018 remains a subject of debate and discussion among wrestling fans. It was a polarizing storyline that challenged expectations and sparked controversy. While opinions may differ on its overall quality, there's no denying its significance in shaping the careers of both Randy Orton and Jinder Mahal. It serves as a reminder that WWE is always willing to take risks and experiment with its product, even if it means deviating from the norm. The rivalry also highlighted the importance of character development, storytelling, and the ability to connect with the audience, factors that ultimately determine the success of any wrestling feud. So, whether you loved it or hated it, the Orton-Mahal rivalry is a chapter in WWE history that won't soon be forgotten.